An argument against death penalty in the eight amendment

The lethal injection room in Florida State Prison. From to July 1,there were 1, executions, of which 1, were by lethal injection, by electrocution, 11 by gas inhalation, 3 by hanging, and 3 by firing squad.

An argument against death penalty in the eight amendment

Top U.S. Stories

This year, 23 people were executed— the second fewest executions in the past 25 years, coming in just behind the 20 inmates who were put to death in But even as the numbers of executions fall, the flaws and controversies surrounding capital punishment could be found in the cases of all the men who were put to death this year.

Inthe people executed argued that bad lawyers, faulty forensic evidence and poor mental health, among other things, brought them to death row.

Several prisoners maintained their innocence until their executions.


All 23 men were put to death by lethal injection. This argument was used throughout the year to little avail, subjecting some to what onlookers said were botched executions. While all 23 cases exhibited the numerous issues surrounding capital punishment, Newsweek has chosen five, each of which highlight the arguments of those who oppose the death penalty.

Reuters Time on death row: After smoking marijuana laced with an unknown substance—thought to be PCP—Gray showed up at the home of musician Brian Harvey, his wife Kathryn, and their two young daughters, Stella and Ruby.

After that, he poured wine on an easel and set the house on fire. Lawyers argued that the jury should consider that Gray had become addicted to drugs as a child to cope with sexual and physical abuse. He was high at the time of the murders, they said, and had become confused by the substances.

Gray was executed by lethal injection in January. Ledell Lee Ledell Lee was executed on April He had been convicted of murdering and sexually assaulting year-old Debra Reese in her home in The microscopic hair analysis method that was used by investigators to incriminate Lee was formally discredited by the FBI and Department of Justice inwhich admitted it could not distinguish specific hairs from others.

One of its difficult-to-obtain drugs in the lethal cocktail used for execution was set to expire at the end of the month. Once he stopped jerking, he moaned and groaned once during a consciousness check before ultimately falling still seven minutes in.

Latest U.S. Headlines

Williams was convicted of killing a former deputy warden after he escaped from prison in a gallon barrel of hog slop in At the time of his escape, he had served less than three weeks of a life term for killing a college cheerleader. Thomas Arthur Thomas Arthur was executed on May Arthur claimed he never committed the crime and his lawyers unsuccessfully argued that he would be exonerated by DNA testing that Alabama refused to undertake.

His lawyers insisted their client would be proven innocent by DNA testing of hair samples found at the scene, but Governor Kay Ivey denied the requests, saying that a jury had already found him guilty with the evidence they were provided.

After his execution, his daughter called for mandatory testing of DNA evidence from capital punishment cases across the country.

But Alabama has started moving in the opposite direction and voted this year to approve a bill that would shorten appeals processes for inmates on death row. He also was the first white man put to death for killing a black person in the state.

Asay was convicted in of fatally shooting Robert Booker after calling him a "n The year-old condemned killer admitted to killing McDowell, but maintained he never murdered Booker. He was the first Florida prisoner to be executed with a new lethal injection protocol that substituted etomidate for midazolam as the first drug in a three-drug cocktail.

Asay's faced numerous challenges throughout his case. One of his lawyers ended up being investigated for shoddy work after a Florida Supreme Court judge found out she had missed critical deadlines for appeals and had kept his records in a shed where they were destroyed by water and vermin.Kennedy v.

Louisiana, U.S. (), is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court of the United States that held that the Eighth Amendment's Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause prohibits imposing the death penalty for the rape of a child in cases where the victim did not die and death .

This includes the Eighth Amendment prohibition of cruel and unusual punishment, so if SCOTUS were to rule that the death penalty is cruel and unusual, only through the Fourteenth Amendment would states be stopped from executing convicted criminals.

An argument against death penalty in the eight amendment

Cruel & Unusual: The Death Penalty v. The Eighth Amendment; Cyber Crimebusters: How Internet Forensics Changed Criminal Investigations; From Mayberry to Martial Law: The Transfer of Military Surplus to Domestic Police; Harsh Justice: Comparing Prisons Around the World; Life in Lockup: An In-depth Look at Reasons for Incarceration in the U.S.

Defendant-appellant Timothy J. McVeigh ("McVeigh") was tried, convicted, and sentenced to death on eleven counts stemming from the bombing of the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building ("Murrah Building") in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, that resulted in the deaths of people. The death penalty was again on the decline in , but the problems that accompany the finality of capital punishment remain..

This year, 23 people were executed—the second fewest executions in. This page includes materials relating to the continuing controversy over the useof the death penalty in many American states. What constitutes a "cruel and unusual punishment" within the meaning of the Eighth Amendment?

Introduction What exactly is a "cruel and unusual punishment" within the meaning of the Eighth Amendment?

Capital Punishment in the United States